Hazrat Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani A FAMOUS BOOK WRITTEN IN DEFENCE OF HAZRAT MUAVIA [R.A] Hazrat Ameer Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Rivayaat By Shaykh Muhammad. Ameer Muawiya Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq Author Mufti Taqi Usmani. May Click to Download Click to Read on Scribd. Post a Comment. For More Islamic Books For More Islamic Books Visit For More I.
|Published (Last):||23 April 2015|
|PDF File Size:||12.64 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.63 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
But I’ll advise you to not rely on me and conduct your own study. I hope you got my point of view. Thank you very much for answering me. I’ll advise you to study that procedure and apply that on haqajq original source of all historical narrations compiled by Tabari.
I’m not in a position to do so. However, information available through Tawatur is something different and exceptional.
The views presented in the books belong to their authors and they are responsible for providing the answer raised on their work. Respected Sister Assalam o alaikum wa Rahmatullah Many thanks for your kind words and comments about my books.
If some Sahaba had something wrong, Allah will not ask us about ajeer but if they were really acquitted from that, we will be held responsible in front of Allah for believing in reports transmitted through doubtful channels.
I respect the author of this book but it seems like he is just playing with the words. Many thanks for your kind words and comments about my books.
Hazrat Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani
I’ll sincerely advise you to leave this matter to Allah. Assalam o alaikum wa Rahmatullah. Large number of narrators who reported the incidents related to the civil wars of companion’s time were biased against the companions. In the first century, even it was not possible to distinguish people as the dispute was only political and not religious. Even we cannot reach at a decisive conclusion about events happening in our life. It is very logical. Nobody believes that Sahaba were free from sin.
It is completely wrong to consider Hazrat Mu’awiya as the person who transformed Khilafat into Malukiyat. You can check by yourselves in the “History of Tabari ” that all reports portraying a sleazy picture of the companions are reported by only five persons and all of them are considered as “liars “. The approach of Tabari was to compile all the narrations whether authentic or not in a chronological order.
Hazrat Muawiya( R. A) Aur Tarikhi Haqaiq : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
It is also reported in some narrations that he changed his decision once he found that a rule has already been established there.
And he did so and the result was in the form of ” Waqia Karbala”. This ameet the history and it cant be denied. If the matter is disturbing you, conduct your own research in the light of above-mentioned procedure. Send at mubashirnazir gmail.
When the matter is only an issue of doubtful reports, why should we form our opinions based on them. If the matter is not much disturbing, I’ll urge you to leave the matter to Allah.
If you know Arabic, you should study the history from its original source. There is a discipline in the historical studies that deals with criticism on historical events. The unchallenged information could only be the one which is available to us by ” Tawatur please see the link below ” which is not sufficient to give us a complete picture of the incident. Regards Respected Sister Wa alaikum us salam wa Rahmatullah The views presented in the books belong to their authors and they are responsible for providing the answer raised on their work.
Why should we not do so in this case and leave the matter to Allah for such people who passed away a long time before us and we do not have reliable information available to put a charge against them. I hope this will clarify my position on that.
Hazrat Ameer Muawiya R-A – [PDF Document]
I repeat the names: On the other side, if we keep a bad opinion about the companions and they were free from such accusations, Allah will definitely hold us accountable.
Because I am the student of history and I know what the Amir Muawia did in his 20 years rule. If a matter with such doubtful information is presented to any court in the world, the judge will not be able to decide the matter and will acquit the suspect based on the benefit of doubt despite of the fact that the suspect and relevant witnesses are available in his court.
But the issue is that we do not have reliable and undisputed information about such incidents. He only compiled the traditions and did not perform evaluation of such reports.
I hope you ll not think that I am a Shia because ‘I am not’. Rest of the books are written on the basis of his compilation. Similarly, Banu A’bbas did the same to defame the Ummayyads.